Wheelchair Ramps

What is the Best Mobility Solution for my Home?

A Guide to Choosing Between a Wheelchair Ramp or Vertical Platform Lift (VPL)

For individuals who rely on mobility devices such as wheelchairs or power scooters, stairs pose a significant obstacle. Without accommodations, entryways, garages, and decks that feature elevation changes and stairs can be difficult, unsafe, or even impossible to access. Vertical platform lifts and ramps are two effective solutions to overcome these challenges. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses. Which option is the best for your home?

Ramps

A wheelchair is simply an inclined plane used to bridge elevation changes. We’ve all used them as they are a common alternative to stairs. For a ramp to be helpful and safe, it’s slope needs to be gradual. The ADA recommends a ramp length of 12 inches for every 1 inch of rise and a platform at the top and bottom. So, if your home has a single 6-inch step at its entrance, you’ll need a 6-foot ramp. At this ratio, ramps can get big very quickly. The average step height in the US is 7.5 inches; using a ramp to assist with an entry with four steps would require 30 feet of ramp. That’s a lot of ramp. Sometimes space won’t allow for the length of ramp needed. And, even if there is space, it’s a challenge to design large wheelchair ramps for stairs in New Orleans that complement and blend with the exterior of a home.

But ramps bring a number of advantages to the table for homeowners. Ramps are relatively inexpensive and require very little ongoing maintenance. Installation is straightforward and flexible design options mean ramps can be configured to meet a wide range of spaces. And ramps are an excellent short-term solution; they can be rented and installed to satisfy temporary needs.

Strengths:

  • Simple solution for low rises
  • Viable option for short-term needs
  • Easy to use and install
  • Flexible design options

Weaknesses:

  • Exposed to the elements. Users are out in the snow and rain while navigating the ramp and the ramp must be kept clear of snow, leaves, and other debris.
  • Impact curb appeal significantly
  • Require some strength to use. The user or caregiver must travel the length of the ramp under their own power or with the assistance of their mobility device.

Vertical Platform Lifts

A vertical platform lift (VPL) is basically a very simple elevator. They feature a gated platform that mechanically lifts and lowers the user. They can be covered, partially enclosed, or completely open. Sometimes VPLs are called porch lifts as they are often used to provide universal access to outdoor porches, decks, or patios. Another common location for VPLs is lower-level garages, an application for which ramps are particularly ill-suited.

Strengths:

  • Good for elevation changes up to about 14 feet.
  • Offers protection from weather for the user
  • Easy to operate for anyone
  • Cost-effective for larger elevation changes
  • Can be temporarily installed in some situations as a short-term solution
  • Has a small footprint for a discrete appearance
  • Requires minimal space
  • Accommodates any type of mobility device, even heavy motorized chairs and scooters

Weaknesses:

  • Requires a firm, flat surface
  • Most practical for long-term installations
  • More expensive than ramps, though the cost differential decreases as the elevation increases.

Wheelchair Ramps for Home

The Bottom Line

If you need a home ramp or home stairlift in New Orleans, contact Southern Mobility Solutions. We’ll conduct a free, in-home consultation to help you explore your options and determine which is best for you. Don’t hesitate. For more freedom and independence at home, call today.